Dr. Barry Friedberg's recent explosive comments about the Murray trial
http://www.prerogativechambers…the-michael-jackson-saga/
Justice in the Face of High-Profile Cases: The People of the State of California v. Conrad Murray, MD — The Michael Jackson Saga
Posted on July 8, 2011 by Dr. Caleb Pilgrim
The death of a celebrity, and involvement therein, can never be a small matter. Thus, I had predicted quite early that Dr. Conrad Murray, cardiologist and Michael Jackson’s “personal physician”, would be prosecuted following Jackson’s death in the weeks before his planned comeback tour in London in 2009.
Some friends, far wiser than myself, disputed this prediction. It seemed unthinkable to them that there was a case to answer on Dr. Murray’s part. In their corner, they have had the support – for different reasons – of Dr. Jack Kevorkian who, almost alone among the medical fraternity, has spoken out in defense of Dr. Murray. In Dr. Kevorkian’s opinion, Mr. Jackson “got what he wanted”. His was a sort of suicide for which Dr. Murray could not be held responsible. But the die has been cast. Dr. Murray now faces a trial in Los Angeles for involuntary manslaughter beginning around May 9, 2011.
For those of us who might still believe in the concept of “luck”, if ever there was an unlucky man, it is probably Dr. Murray. In May 2009 he apparently entered a contract with Mr. Jackson and his tour promoters, Anschutz Entertainment Group, AEG Live, a leading sports and entertainment company, whereby he would be paid approximately US $150,000 a month. On June 25, 2009, Mr. Jackson died after cardiac arrest – less than two months after Dr. Murray had started working for him, pursuant to his contract. Dr. Murray was apparently never paid any money. It is easy in hindsight to say that the doctor could have seen the offer of such money and left it where it was, a glittering prospect which faded all too soon like a chimera in the desert. His practice and his reputation might well have remained unblemished by the tragic events which subsequently unfolded. But the loss of his wages, although substantial, was by no means as serious as the trial he now faces.
The Coroner’s autopsy report of about August 19, 2009 stated that the manner of Jackson’s death was a homicide based on the following:
1.The circumstances indicated that the propofol and the benzodiazepines were administered by another;
2.The propofol was administered in a non-hospital setting without any appropriate medical indication;
3.The standard of care for administering propofol was not met. Recommended equipment for patient monitoring, precision dosing, and resuscitation was not present;
4.The circumstances did not support self-administration of propofol.
As to the use of propofol in this particular case, the Coroner stated that “[T]here are NO reports of its (propofol’s) use for insomnia relief, to my knowledge. The only reports of use in homes are cases of fatal abuse (first reported in 1992), suicide, murder and accident”.
Dr. Murray’s trial – the People of the State of California v. Conrad Robert Murrray, Case No: SA 073164 – will soon start before the Los Angeles Superior Court. A jury will be empanelled. Prospective jurors will state under oath, as is typical, that they can be fair and impartial to both Dr. Murray and the People of the State of California, and that they will follow the law that the judge gives to them.
Yet, it may well be difficult for Dr. Murray to get a fair trial. The enormous pre-trial publicity makes it unlikely that any prospective juror would not be familiar with, if not pre-disposed to some version of the “facts” of the case. Thus, the various newspapers have written that Dr. Murray had financial problems, that he fathered his seventh child, Che Giovanni Murray – born shortly before Jackson’s death – by a woman who was allegedly a former stripper and exotic dancer, that he was allegedly delinquent in other child support payments, that he spent substantial time talking to others, including another girlfriend, on the telephone when he ought to have been looking after his patient, that at the time he treated Mr. Jackson he had neither the proper equipment nor an anesthetist trained and experienced in administering propofol or resuscitating patients, that he administered propofol to Mr. Jackson outside of a proper clinical/hospital setting, that he failed to administer CPR effectively, that he even hid medication from paramedics on the day Jackson died, and so on.
By contrast, and less well known are the claims, per Joseph Jackson’s complaint to the California Medical Board – against AEG – that Dr. Murray had requested that the tour’s organizers, AEG Live, provide him with life saving CPR equipment and a nurse or a “qualified assistant medical person”. It is further alleged that during the contract negotiations, Dr. Murray received an e-mail explaining that the contract was delayed because it was a “rare event” for a physician to be hired to care for a singer on tour. The relevant contract appears to have been signed by Dr. Murray on or about June 24, 2009, the day before Jackson died. A police affidavit allegedly stated that Dr. Murray told police that Jackson craved propofol to treat his insomnia, and referred to the drug as his “milk”. There appears to have been small traces of the drug in Jackson’s digestive system. During the preliminary hearing this past January, a prosecution witness conceded that it was plausible that Jackson “self-ingested” some propofol. Important as these facts are, they still do not absolve Dr. Murray. At best, they may assist civil litigation by Jackson’s Estate against AEG.
Dr. Murray may face yet another dilemma. He apparently assisted the police for some hours shortly after the singer’s death. It is not clear that he requested that his lawyer(s) be present, or that they were present for all of those interviews in which he “assisted” the police. In all probability, his lawyers may now have to confront any inconsistent statements or even admissions he may have made against his penal interest during the many hours in which he “assisted” the police.
Dr. Murray is also entitled to a jury of his peers. He is a West Indian, from Grenada and Trinidad. He still speaks with a pronounced West Indian accent, as evident to anyone who heard his statements proclaiming his innocence. He is also a cardiologist, and educated professional. Arguably, any jury selected for his trial in Los Angeles will not be a jury of his peers, and such a jury need not necessarily be sympathetic to the alien in their midst.
The Jackson family members, near and far now want someone to answer for the entertainer’s death. They maintain that “Michael was murdered”. Jesse Jackson and others too have had their say. With such enormously negative publicity comes the risk that Dr. Murray cannot get a fair trial.
In conclusion, I make one further prediction. Dr. Murray will at the end of his trial be found guilty of involuntary manslaughter. He will most probably be imprisoned, as a result. In sum, he will have lost far more than he gained, the excessive international notoriety, the loss of his professional licenses to practice medicine, loss of income, even the risk of personal harm by some deranged fan in or out of jail, and more important his peace of mind. Much will depend on the testimony of the witnesses, but barring a miracle, for Dr. Murray “this is it.
Dr. Caleb Pilgrim, Attorney-at-Law
-----------------------------------------------------------------
..dazu der Kommentar/Antwort von Dr. Friedberg ![]()
Barry L. Friedberg, M.D. says:
July 11, 2011 at 5:18 pm
In a California that could not convict the clearly guilty OJ Simpson, it is not clear that a conviction can be obtained for the equally guilty Conrad Murray.
That being said, no amount of defense attorney posturing or attempts to create reasonable doubt can ever relieve Murray of his responsibility to have watched and monitored Jackson.
I was interviewed by Michael Flanagan, one of Murray’s defense attorneys, as the first anesthesiologist chosen to be a witness on behalf of Murray’s defense.
Prior to this interview, when I had written the Michael Jackson chapter in ‘Getting Over Going Under,’ I assumed Murray was over his clinical training and expertise giving propofol .
Flanagan dispelled that impression when he described how Murray gave propofol for cardioversions (electrical activity delivered to a heart with atrial rhythm disturbance). Flanagan said, ‘Murray did not even start an intravenous. He simply ‘mainlined’ the propofol directly into a vein.’
I told Flanagan that he impressed me but not at all in the manner in which he had hoped.
There is no word in the English language to describe the recklessness of Murray ‘mainlining’ propofol for cardioversion. Not even a day one intern right our of medical school would be so reckless and cavalier.
The only thing more reckless than Murray’s conduct at Jackson’s home would have been to have taken Jackson up in a plane and pushed him out without a parachute.
‘Mainlining’ propofol along with Murray’s failure to provide child support for the multiple illegitimate children he has fathered with multiple women & his long history of failure to honor other financial obligations leads me to reassess my diagnosis of Murray’s personality.
Murray is the ‘poster child’ for Sociopaths of America.
He is not an ignorant fool but a person who does not think the norms of behavior apply to him.
When he disclaims responsibility for the death of Michael Jackson, it is the sociopath speaking who is convinced of his own words and clearly believes he will convince a jury as well.
Another attempt to rehabilitate Murray’s image to the public included a release saying he had never been sued for malpractice. As if never being sued would be to give testimony to his wonderful doctoring. An informed listener should quickly recognize this record is a greater testimony to a sociopath’s slick talking, not to great doctoring.
Do not believe a single Murray utterance that cannot be independently confirmed.
Sadly, even if convicted and deprived of a license to practice medicine, Murray is unlikely to stop practicing. The rules just don’t apply to him, at least, in his mind anyway.