October 10, 2011
Conrad police interview may backfire for prosecutors. Here's why.
Posted: 01:59 PM ET
conrad2010.jpg
Commentary by Keith Sullivan, special to HLN
We can still only speculate on how the audio of Dr. Conrad Murray being interviewed by police will ultimately impact the jurors. But, one thing is for sure: it definitely will cause them to begin formulating new opinions and impressions of Dr. Murray.
And they may not be the kind of opinions prosecutors were hoping for Friday when they rolled out this significant piece of evidence.
During the interview, Dr. Murray is heard sounding calm, methodical and well-prepared in his responses. In fact, he is even slightly defensive or protective of himself when describing why the drug propofol was even being utilized and how it was administered. Clearly, this shows a guy who knew there likely would be very serious consequences for Michael's death and he wanted to make sure they did not fall on him.
Dr. Murray can be heard trying to justify the use of propofol as something Michael insisted on and was very familiar with and accustomed to administering himself.
Sounds beneficial for the defense, but jurors may ask themselves, "Should the patient be dictating to the physician the best course of treatment?" And is this even the truth or is this just Dr. Murray being a "spin doctor" and trying to manipulate the facts into a more favorable story for himself?
Still, there remains ample reason to think playing the tapes might actually help Dr. Murray's defense.
For two weeks he has sat there as the accused, the condemned, the 'evil doctor' who couldn't do anything right. But now he tells his story in open court. Most importantly, he gets to do so and is not subject to cross-examination by the prosecution!
That is extremely beneficial if the jury accepts his taped words as truth.
The other benefit of the taped evidence is that for the first time, Dr. Murray is humanized as he is heard talking in a soft, calm and compassionate tone. The jurors hear his voice in full conversation mode and they listen to his first-hand detailed explanation of the frantic scene that played out in the bedroom as he frantically tried to save Michael Jackson.
Again, this could also be beneficial, though only if jurors believed what they heard.
The police interrogation tapes will continue to be played in court on Tuesday.
Do you think the content of the tapes will prove more beneficial to the prosecution or defense? Tell us in the comments below or either on Twitter @HLNTV or Facebook.
Complete courtroom coverage of the Conrad Murray trial airs live on HLN from gavel to gavel. It’s also on In Session on truTV from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. ET every weekday.