For me The Girl Is Mine is the one remix that took the most getting used to. Especially that incessant "she mine, she mine" - I really do like the beat and everything, but I really could do without that "she mine, she mine"...
Still, I'm getting used to it though and I love the new "dimension" to this song. It sounds totally different and you gotta give props to Will.I.Am for making a nice and proper R&B club tune out of absolute kitsch.
I was really in two minds about Beat It before I heard it. It was really weird because Beat It is such a rock tune in its original form. I couldn't see how Will.I.Am - the über-R&B-producer could remix this without totally ruining it.
I was very much surprised (in a good way) though when I heard it. I mean, Fergie can't sing to save her life, and you can tell even in this remix (but not as much as usual, thanks to Will :lol) - but considering that they seem to have simply tried to put a bit of a modern R&B spin on the song, they've done a remarkably good job. Nowhere near the original (obviously...), but a good club tune. A great club tune. I really like that running bass thing they did towards the end, that really fast paced bass.
I gotta say I'm still a bit on the fence about Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'.
Akon's voice is a total nightmare for this song... The original is such a master-piece and while the remix does a good job of revisiting and sort of shining a new light on it, Akon's voice really lessens the quality of a remix that may otherwise well have become my favorite.
The remix itself is really good and the bits where you hear MJ only are outstanding. But Akon's voice is HORRIBLE.
P.Y.T. is another one that I took my time with making my mind up about. Compared with the original demo of PYT, this is a great imrpovement and a really original new take on the song. But compared to the final cut that made it on to Thriller, I'm not so sure. I did decide in the end that you can't really compare this PYT remix with the PYT from Thriller because the final version of PYT is so totally different compared to the demo that this new song is a remix.
Keeping that in mind I have to say, I LOVE it. The horn-sections are simply fantastic, the beat is the BOMB and the bridges between the verses and choruses ROCK! That girl's a P... the girl's a Y... the girl's a T... it sounds perfect.
![]()
Kanye's Billie Jean remix had an instant effect on me. The WOW-effect. Amazin, amazing, amazing. It is, by far, the best Michael Jackson remix I have ever heard. It really captures that loneliness, the craziness of the lyrics... It's a bit like a grown-up version of the original Billie Jean. Like it's not the 20 year old Mike singing about something taking place now - instead it's a 50 year old Michael. A wiser Michael, looking back and telling the story. And in spite of this more mature sound it remains vibrant and dynamic and dancable.
Really an amazing remix.
I think, at the end of the day, it's important we don't forget that comparing these remixes with their original counterparts is absolutely unfair.
Thriller isn't the best selling album of all time for nothing. The reason is, the music is f*cking awesome man!!! (Well that and the amazing videos and great marketing - but really it's the music.)
You cannot improve upon that, it's pointless to even try. What Michael and the remixes probably did (that is, at least, what it looks like to me) is, they sort approached the songs from a totally different direction. Sort of try and see where it goes. And really - it's remixes. I've never heard a remix that was better than the original song. Well, apart from Ignition by R. Kelly.